Update: Response to the response of Scanlime’s Perler Bead Hopper Sorting Suggestion

I wrote the other day about a Perler bead hopper for a Perler Bead “printer” that Scanlime is working on. Well, she responded on her blog with much more explanation: http://scanlime.org/2011/02/perler-bead-robot-ideas/ I had a lot to write in response to that.

Here is my response:

I really like the technical challenge of this project. I personally don’t have a need for a perler bead “printer” but it’s an awesome concept, challenge and project.

I really like the gate idea or a variation on it. Such as the “looking ahead” idea, but look ahead let’s say four or five beads and planning the course based on that. It would take more processing power to plan that far ahead. A propeller probably could handle that.

I’m not sure what part of the 3D-printed disc is tapered. Could you please explain that a little better?

I agree with keeping it simple. I now realize that my idea would cost more in 3D printing time and cost more for multiple motors and bearings. Using servos and a radial coordinate system saves a lot of money. No need for precision rods, timing belts, stepper motors or pulleys. Using what bead you get and then choosing the closest place to put it seems much more efficient than I had assumed(incorrectly) from the description, “…to direct it toward the build surface or to a discard pile.”

“Or we could run the sorting and placing tasks concurrently, with the placing task waiting on more beads when it runs out of a particular color.” If you could combine that with a method to move on to the next color and then come back to the color with the low number of beads when there is a sufficient amount in the hopper it may be even more efficient.

I think I might try a variation on my idea, just for sorting, maybe with skittles or m&ms. It seems like it’d be a fun project.

I’ve learned a lot from your post(Scanlime), for my own projects:

1) I need to figure out and decide what my goals and requirements are for projects before I start them.

2) There are many more ways than one to solve a problem. I need to think of all the possibilities first and not dismiss them so quickly.

3) I need to think more outside the box.

4) I should try to think of the extremes and not only within the limitations I see.

P.s. I realized that a lot of the really awesome projects I have seen on Hack a Day and Makezine blog have been made by you, Scanlime. Thank you for the awesome things you do and make!